MINUTES
of
The Annual General Meeting of the Canadian Shark Class Association
The Meeting commenced at approximately 11:05 a.m.
with John Brunt, CSCA President, acting as Chairman.
The Chairman submitted his report and introduced
Julian Aziz, Treasurer; Vince Lehman, V.P., Racing; and Jeff Mitchell,
V.P., Specifications who were also present at the head table.
The President’s report is attached to the Minutes
of the Meeting.
Secretary’s Report
The Secretary of the Association was unable to attend
the Meeting. As a result, no report was submitted. The President’s
report dealt with several issues, including mailing of membership forms
and renewals as well as reporting a slight increase in membership in
2002.
Treasurer’s Report
Julian Aziz submitted the financial statements for
the fiscal period ending February 28, 2003.
Bill Henderson, Website Report
Bill Henderson submitted a website report on
Sharkbytes which reported with respect to the traffic on the website,
the ability to communicate with the membership and the approximate costs
associated therewith. Bill continues to require assistance with
maintaining the site and would like volunteers to contact him.
Specifications Report
Jeff Mitchell, VP Specifications, reported on the
number of boats that were measured as well as issuing, on behalf of the
ISCA Specifications Committee, rule clarifications with respect to the
use of a compression posts and the glassing over of the hull deck joint.
The report of the V.P., Specifications is attached hereto. The
clarifications issued will form part of Appendix IV of the Constitution,
Class Rules and Specifications.
2003 Racing Schedule
Vince Lehmann, V.P. Racing, reported on the Counter
Regattas from last year as well as the proposed schedule of events for
2003. He also indicated that the 2003 Racing Schedule had been posted on
Sharkbytes.
Mail-In Vote
The Chairman explained that the mail-in vote had
received 39 votes of which 34 were for the amendment of the fiscal
year-end of the Association to run from the period of April 1st
to March 31st of the following year. This proposal was
originally put to the 2001 Annual General Meeting of the Canadian Shark
Class Association which took place in February of 2002. The results of
the vote indicated that 36 were for and 2 were against with 1
abstention.
The Chairman made a motion for the confirmation of
the mail-in vote results for the amendment of the fiscal period which
was passed with the unanimous consent of the Meeting.
The Chairman also reported on the results of the
mail-in vote with respect to the increase in membership dues. The
results were 32 in favour of the increase and 7 against. The Chairman
then indicated that the Executive determined that an increase in the
membership fees was not warranted in light of the fact that Sharkscan
was not published and the Executive was unlikely to increase the dues in
2004 unless Sharkscan had been published. The issue of Sharkscan was
discussed more fully later in the Meeting.
ISCA Report
Greg Cockburn delivered the report of the
International Shark Class Association, including in particular the
success of the recent Worlds at Mimico Cruising Club in August of 2002.
Election of Officers
The Chairman indicated to the Meeting that,
notwithstanding that the Notice of Meeting had indicated that all
officers intended to stand for re-election, Don Melick, the Executive
Vice-President, had indicated that he would not be running again. The
Chairman reported that Jin Frati had been nominated to run for the
position and that he had accepted the nomination. The nomination was
then seconded and unanimously carried.
There were no other nominations from the floor with
respect to any other positions and the Executive was acclaimed.
Other Business
Flags for Shark of the Year were awarded to the
winners as follows:
1st Place - Steve Ellwood, Ockam’s Razor
2nd Place - Jeff Mitchell, Frankly
Scarlett
3rd Place - Greg Cockburn, Eager for More
4th Place - Jack Mitchell, Crackerjack
5th Place - Moe Reigner, Sponge Worthy
Ottawa Worlds Presentation
Eric Calvert from the Organizing Committee for the
Ottawa Shark Worlds 2003 provided a report on both fundraising and
proposed schedule of events. He invited all parties to participate in
the 2003 Shark Worlds.
Golden Horseshoe Championships
Sheri Gay, from the Royal Hamilton Yacht Club,
provided information with respect to the Golden Horseshoe Championships
are being run in conjunction with LYRA August 1, 2 & 3rd.
2003. The discussion was whether it would be a two-day or a three-day
event being comprised as the Friday, Saturday and Sunday or simply the
Saturday and Sunday. After discussion, the Chairman put forth a motion
confirming that the Golden Horseshoe Championships in conjunction with
LYRA be a three-day event. The motion was passed unanimously by parties
voting on the issue.
Fleet Development Fund
The Chairman indicated that a request had been made
for money from the Fleet Development Fund and that there are currently
surplus funds available in the Fleet Development Fund for use in events.
The Chairman requested at the Meeting whether or not there was any
discussion as to use of the funds or guidance upon which a decision to
expend funds could be made. The Chairman reported to the Meeting that
the implementation of the development fund was unclear as to the
specific purpose for which funds may be expended and that the Executive
Committee was looking for that guidance. There was no discussion as to
the specific events and the matter will be left to the discretion of the
Executive. The Chairman then invited submissions from those interested
in utilizing Fleet Development Funds for their events. The suspension of
the collection of the Fleet Development Fund continues in effect for the
2003 sailing season.
Sharkscan
A discussion with respect to the publication of
Sharkscan took place at the Meeting. Jane McArthur is currently the
Sharkscan editor and indicated that one of the fundamental issues with
respect to Sharkscan was the contribution of content for same from the
membership. It was also discussed that the need for Sharkscan continues
to decrease given the increased use of Sharkbytes by all members. The
Chairman indicated at the Meeting that regatta reports from regatta
organizers should continue to be delivered for publication on Sharkbytes
and should be considered for utilization in the event of a publication.
Discussion also focused on providing this information in a compiled
form, either by way of CD Rom, .pdf files or other electronic means,
which would be available to the membership at the end of the year.
No motions with respect to Sharkscan were passed at
the Meeting.
Open Discussion
The Chairman then indicated that the Meeting was open
for discussion and introduced the topic of measurement. The Chairman
summarized information which had been provided to the membership at the
Meeting. The Chairman also indicated his views on the approach to
addressing measurement issues.
Ian Dawson then moved the following motion:
"The Meeting nominate a 6-member CSCA
technical specifications subcommittee to report at the 2004 AGM.
This committee shall be struck by July 26 through a nomination
selection process managed by the President of ISCA. Its membership
shall be comprised of two members west of North Shore, South Shore
and Golden Horseshoe by two members east of North Shore, South Shore
and Golden Horseshoe and two from within the North Shore, South
Shore and Golden Horseshoe."
A discussion ensued on this motion. The Chairman of
the Meeting asked for volunteers to stand on the specifications
committee in addition to those currently on the committee. Steve Ellwood
was the only volunteer who indicated his willingness to stand for the
committee. Steve is currently a member of the North Shore Shark Class
Association which has sufficient representation on the committee.
The motion was seconded and voted upon. The motion
was defeated by a majority of the membership. At the present time there
is no change in the membership of the current constitution of the
Specifications Committee.
Bill McNaughton then proposed a number of motions.
The Chairman attempted to separate the motions and individual motions
were then passed with respect to the following matters.
First motion proposed by Bill McNaughton:
"The current specifications committee will endeavour to have
published on Sharkbytes on or before June 1, 2003 a copy of all current
rulings and clarifications which have been issued by both ISCA and CSCA
with respect to the rules in general and with respect to any individual
boats."
This motion was seconded and passed by a majority of
members of the Meeting.
Second motion proposed by Bill McNaughton: "The
specifications committee endeavour to review the current specifications
and publish on or before September 1, 2003 a list of matters which
should be put to the membership for either clarification or specific
ruling relating to any issues of measurement determined to require
amendment or clarification."
This motion was seconded and passed by a majority of
the membership at the Meeting.
Third motion proposed by Bill McNaughton: "That
pending clarification of any outstanding rules, any boat which has been
issued a measurement certificate, shall be considered to continue to
comply with the rules pending the issuance of these
clarifications."
After discussion, including input from the Chairman,
that all boats should continue to comply with the rules and that the
granting of a measurement certificate should not allow boats that do not
comply with the rules to continue to compete, the motion was
subsequently withdrawn and not voted upon.
Chairman's Note: Subsequent to the AGM, the
Specifications Committee determined that with respect to certain
specific items, it may be more fair and equitable to permit those
matters which will be subject to possible rule clarifications to be
permitted during 2003 if the modification has been completed and a
formal clarification has not been finalized. Members should not rely on
any potential clarification until it has been formally issued and posted
on Sharkbytes and therefore should ensure full compliance of their boats
with the rules.
A motion was made to then adjourn the Meeting and the
Meeting was adjourned at approximately 1:55 p.m.